Using Wikipedia as a source has been a
very controversial subject. It's
said to be unreliable because it's content is written and submitted
by anonymous internet users. This meaning any regular Joe with
internet access can write up a bunch of fiction about a politician he
dislikes or something of the like.
Citing Wikipedia as a source has been
banned by elementary schools, high schools, and post-secondary
schools for as long as Wikipedia has been running (about 12 years if
you're curious).
There are good reasons behind this, especially from a journalistic standpoint. I heard a horror story in one of my lectures this previous semester. I wish I remembered the details so I could find it on the web, but alas, it is elusive. Maybe it's a variation of generic tale that all journalism professors tell their students. The story goes that a rookie journalist was in a rush to complete a story, a bright and time-saving idea popped into his head and off to Wikipedia he went. He skimmed through an article about the prominent person he was writing his piece on. His story was written and his editor was no longer breathing down his neck. That is, until the publication gets a call from that prominent person's lawyer. The main facts in the journalist's story were all wrong, publication gets sued, and that rookie journalist's butt is kicked firmly to the curb.
There is one thing to keep in mind though. In December 2005, an online daily science journal called Nature conducted an experiment. They sent articles from both Wikipedia and Encyclopedia Britannica to experts in the field relevant to each set of articles. The articles were then compared side by side with out the expert knowing which article came from which source. Forty-two usable reviews were returned. There were mistakes from both sources such as factual errors, misleading statements, and misunderstandings of concepts. Out of all these errors, Wikipedia was found to have 162 errors, while Encyclopedia Britannica had 123. That's not a big difference at all.
From what I remember from high school, my classmates and I took the no-Wikipedia rule as "do not even go NEAR Wikipedia or you will fail this assignment". What I'm arguing is that Wikipedia is one of the best places, in my experience, to start your research. What that poor shmuck in the story above did not do is check the sources at the end of the Wikipedia article. This is a gold mine, ladies and gentlemen. This may kind of seem like a no brainer, but you'd be surprised about how many people don't think of this (myself included).
![]() |
| Look at all of those sources all in one place. I just happened to be reading about Macchu Picchu when writing this. |
In short: use Wikipedia but don't use it as your only source, whether it be for school or for a job, or even if you're trying to prove your friend wrong. Despite the study that found Wikipedia to be almost as accurate as Encyclopedia Britannica, always check at least one other source to verify the facts. I feel that's best practice for any situation. I've always found Wikipedia to be a great place to get a brief overview of the topic so I know what I want to focus more on or learn more about as well.
How do you feel about using Wikipedia as a source? Whether it be professionally, academically, or for entertainment?

No comments:
Post a Comment